I wouldn't kick any of them out of bed, but, if I was forced to only pick 1, below are my thoughts:
1. Joe would have to bottom repeatedly throughout the night;
2. Nick would top and would have been requested to not wear any deodorant for 2 days prior; and
3. Kevin would have to flip fuck throughout the night.
Being that Nick and Joe are too worried about their looks and Kevin has been married to that rather unattractive chick that looks like she could open a can with her nose, I'd pick Kevin. He looks like he needs to get out a lot of sexual frustration and I'd be glad to help him. I'd drop him off at home the next morning drenched in cum, lube and sweat.